Immunologic Disorders of the Inner Ear
St George ENT
-Normal development:
stem cells (in bone marrow) Þ T- or B- lymphocytes.
T cells (mature via passage thru thymus) into:
(1) helper T cells; (aid and promote B-cell antibody production)
(2) suppressor T cells (modulate A/B prodn & responses mediated by T cells)
(3) cytotoxic T cells (capable of direct killing of cells expressing foreign antigens)
Collectively, responsible for; LK production, anti-viral cytotoxicity, graft-versus-host dis
delayed HS’ty responses, and graft rejection.
B cells (mature via passage thru fetal liver)
form IgM molecule that ultimately is incorporated into the cell membrane.
AUTOIMMUNITY
-autoimmune may result from reaction of antibodies or cells against self-constituents.
-disorders are considered:
- organ-specific (eg DM) or non-organ-specific diseases (eg SLE).
-3 primary mechanisms for autoimmune disorders:
1. autoantibodies against tissue antigens which attach to specific cell surface Ag’s, fix complement,
and result in tissue damage and organ dysfunction.
2. deposition of antigen-antibody immune complexes within tissues. (CIC’s)
3. destruction of tissue by specific activated cytotoxic T cells.
-role of genetic factors in the susceptibility and development of autoimmune disease;
eg; major histocompatibility genes (esp HLA-DR alleles)
EXPERIMENTAL IMMUNOLOGY OF INNER EAR
- immunoglobulin X’s blood-labyrinthine barrier & is found in perilymph at 1/1000 concentration found in serum ( analogous to BBB)
- inner ear has the property of concentrating immunoglobulins
- main immunoglobulins in perilymph are IgG, with lesser amounts of IgM and IgA
-endolymphatic sac
-secretory component and IgA have been found in epithelial cells (Arnold1984).
-has been suggested as site of host defenses within inner ear
-normal mouse has full complement of immunocompetent cells including macrophages, PMNs, IgM-
and IgG-plasma cells, and T-helper cells (Takahashi and Harris, 1988b).
-Examination of inner ears undergoing immune reactions reveals:
-many inflammatory cells in scala tympani, perisaccular connective tissue, endolymphatic sac lumen
-early in this response, PMN’s & macrophages predominate Ý IL-2levels; but over time, T-helper &
plasma cells predominate with gradual emergence of T-s cells by 3/52, to halt inflammation.
-cells enter inner ear via: spiral modiolar veins along a bony conduit into the scala tympani or
venules surrounding the endolymphatic duct and sac.
-Expt’s show endolymphatic sac provides an immunologic role for the inner ear in addition to its water-
resorptive role, analogous to gut.
-Expt’s have shown that cochlea is not a passive organ on exposure to a pathogen and that an immune
response can develop to protect and preserve cochlear function.
-Expt’s have shown that on the other hand, immune responses can be injurious to organ function if the inciting
antigen evokes a sufficiently vigorous response
(eg viruses may =>hydrops if they reach and replicate within sac epithelium)
-Exp’t of inoculating live CMV into immunosuppressed animals:
- two major findings:
1. a significant reduction in inflammatory response within cochlea following immunosuppression
2. immunosuppressed animals showed significantly preserved hearing compared to controls.
Þ the host's response to the invading organism causes the majority of damage rather than the
cytopathic effects of the virus itself
EXPERIMENTAL ALLERGIC LABYRINTHITIS
-Yoo 1983 developmed an animal model with inner ear injury secondary to type II collagen autoimmunity.
-their animals demonstrated spiral ganglion cell degeneration, atrophy of organ of Corti, arteritis of VIII & stria vascularis, endolymph hydrops with atrophy of surface epithelium of endolymph duct.
- Hearing loss and vestibular dysfunction.
-these studies => autoimmunity to type II collagen may underlie: ? otosclerosis, Meniere's disease, and SNHL nb: several studies done since that have& haven’t confirmed these findings.
-??Existence of other specific anticochlear autoantibody.
-etiology of autoimmunity is unknown, but one theory suggests that:
-tissues involved in this process are of either ectodermal or endodermal origin and are viewed as foreign by the immune system, which is mesodermal.
nb:entire membranous labyrinth is of ectodermal origin.
CLINICAL AUTOIMMUNE DISEASE OF THE INNER EAR
-autoimmune disease affecting ear may be either result of:
-organ-specific disease or
-result of a systemic disorder.
-Eg: Veldman 1984 reported autoimmune SNHL resulted from:
-immune complex-induced vasculitis,
-defect in PMN leukocytes,
-postvaccination serum sickness.
(A) Systemic disorders
Polyarteritis nodosa
-defn: systemic disorder affecting small- and medium-sized arteries throughout body,
-incid: only rarely associated with cochlear injury.
-clin: although this is a systemic disorder, hearing loss may be the sole presenting symptom (Bakaar, 1978)
-histopathology: -arteritis in internal auditory artery with wide-spread cochleovestibular ischemic changes, osteoneogenesis and fibrous tissue in the basilar turns.
-others: necrotizing vasculitis Þ disappearance of organ of Corti, atrophy of stria vascularis, collapse of Reissner's membr, distortion of tectorial membr, fibrosis of apical turn. ---Nb: search for such an etiology of vasculitis should be made in patients with profound unexplained deafness.
Cogan's syndrome
-defn: disorder of young adults cxtz’d by nonsyphilitic interstitial keratitis (IK)& vertibuloauditory dysfunction -aetiol: ?? hypersensitivity response to infectious agents associated with vasculitis (Cheson et al., 1976).
-clin: -IK develops suddenly with photophobia, lacrimination, and eye pain, gradually resolves
-vestib-audit sx are: acute episodes of vertigo, tinnitus, and hearing loss (Þ deafness over 1-3mnths)
-occasionally associated with systemic Sx’s, arthritis, PAN, GN, inflam bowel disease, splenomegaly
-atypical Cogan's syndrome
-vestibulo-auditory symptoms 1 to 6 months before or after the onset of IK
-vestibuloauditory symptoms plus episcleritis, uveitis, or conjunctivitis
-histo: endolymphatic hydrops, plasma cell & lymphocytic infiltration of spiral ligament
saccular rupture, osteoneogenesis of RW, spiral ganglion cell degeneration, degeneration of stria.
degeneration of organ of Corti, fibrosis and osteoneogenesis within perilymphatic space.
Vogt-Koyanagi-Harada syndrome (VKH).
-similarites to Cogan's syndrome
-characterized by SNHL, dizziness, granulomatous uveitis, depigmentation of hair and skin around eyes,
loss of eyelashes, and aseptic meningitis.
-etiopathogenesis is ?? autoimmunity to:
(1) melanocytes
(2) tissues containing these cells,( uvea, skin, meninges, and inner ear).
Wegener's granulomatosis
-classic triad consists of:
(1) necrotizing granulomas with vasculitis of upper and lower respiratory tracts,
(2) systemic vasculitis, and
(3) focal necrotizing glomerulitis
-ear manifestations occurred in 20% of patients
-most often serous otitis media associated with infection or obstruction of the nasopharynx.
-some patients had sensorineural losses, and some of these improved with prednisone therapy.
nb:may be the sole presenting symptom of these patients.
-etiology of the inner ear disease is unknown ???? necrotizing vasculitis.
-dx:. (cANCA: antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibody) test Þ (+’ve in 95% of pts with Wegener's: Schur 1991) -it recognizes antibodies to azurophilic granules in neutrophils.
Relapsing polychondritis
-defn: a rare disease ctzed by recurrent episodes of inflammatory necrosis affecting cartilaginous structures of
ears, nose, URT, & peripheral joints (McAdam, 1976).
-clin: -it destroys supporting cartilage, Þ auricular deformity or saddle nose deformity or tracheal collapse.
-associated with vestibuloauditory symtoms
-the erythema spares the lobula but involves the remainder of the pinna equally.
ddx: bacterial perichondritis and erysipelas.
-bacterial perichondritis exhibits fluctuation if the entire pinna is involved;
-erysipelas involves entire auricle, x’tnds onto periauricular skin with a well-demarcated margin.
-aetiol: immune-mediated rather than an infectious cause.
-mx: antiinflammatory agents good in reversing the inflammation and SNHL in this disorder.
Other rare systemic vasculitises:
-Takayasu's arteritis, postvaccination vasculitis, and serum sickness in which an occasional incidence
of vertibuloauditory dysfunction has been seen (Mair and Elverland, 1977; Rosen, 1949).
-basic underlying pathologic condition is vasculitis, Þ ischemic injury to inner ear.
Systemic lupus erythematosus
-defn: a multisystem disease that has protean manifestations.
-malar "butterfly rash" is pathognomonic but present in relatively few patients.
-Polyarthralgia, arthritis, pleuritis, pericarditis, pneumonitis, myocarditis, endocarditis, nephritis, cranial nerve
palsies, meningitis, cerebrovascular accidents, neuritis, scleritis, retinal degeneration secondary to vasculitis,
& inflammatory bowel disease are all part of the clinical spectrum of this disease (Steinberg1984; Tan 1982). -Otologic manifestations include:
chronic otitis media with necrotizing vasculitis and progressive SNHL or disequilibrium (McCabe,
-laboratory abnormalities include Ý ESR, circulating immune complexes,& multiple autoantibodies.
Rheumatoid arthritis
- chronic systemic inflammatory disease mainly affects joints.
- Extraarticular manifestations include: vasculitis, muscle atrophy, subcutaneous nodules, lymphadenopathy, splenomegaly, and leukopenia.
- Otologic manifestations Þ vestibuloauditory dysfunction.
(B) Organ-specific autoimmune inner ear disease
-cell-mediated immunity is implicated by studies of Hughes et al. (1986) and Berger et al. (1989).
-other studies: ??? autoantibodies (ANA, anticardiolipin, antismooth muscle, antiendoplasmic reticulum)
Ménière's disease
???? autoimmune etiology (Ryan, 1987).
-elevated circulating immune complexes and other immunologic abnormalities in patients with this disorder.
-Yoo reported an elevated type II collagen autoantibody level in patients with Ménière's disease & otosclerosis. Autoimmunity to type II collagen experimentally Þ wide-spread inner ear dysfunction
(that is, hearing loss, vestibular dysfunction, and endolymphatic hydrops).
TREATMENT
-Patients with clear-cut evidence of autoimmunity and whose deafness/disequilibrium are disabling:
Þ immunosuppressive regimen.
-Generally, 1-2 mg/kg/day (usual dose 60 mg) of prednisone for 4 weeks
Patients with a beneficial response Þ high dose for an additional 1-2 months, then taper down slowly.
-In nonresponsive but desperate cases, cyclophosphamide can then be added (2-5 mg/kg/day)
-taken each morning with liberal fluid intake to lessen the risks of urinary bladder toxicity.
-peripheral blood should be monitored so that total WCC does not drop below 3000 cells/mm3,
nor the neutrophil count below 1000 to 1500/mm3.
-McCabe's treatment regimen:
-patients are given an initial trial of high-dose steroids for 3 weeks,
-those who respond Þ escalated to a cyclophosphamide-prednisolone combination for 3-mnth period; cyclophosphamide is then discontinued, and the prednisolone is slowly tapered.
-any drop in hearing is followed by reinstitution of the full combination of drugs at original dosages
S/E’s of cyclophosphamide: hemorrhagic cystitis and malignancies of urinary tract, leukemogenic.
-In cases in which humoral immune mechanisms are more apparent:
-plasmapheresis can be considered (Luetje, 1989).
-during plasmapheresis, cyclophosphamide and steroids should be continued.
Nb: in Wegener's granulomatosis and Cogan's syndrome, aggressive immunosuppressive therapy for 1 year
after the disappearance of active disease (Fauci and Wolfe, 1973; Fauci et al., 1978).
IMMUNOASSAYS
Lymphocyte transformation
-phytohemagglutinin (PHA), a lectin from kidney beans, caused the transformation of small lymphocytes into proliferating lymphocytes when cocultured in vitro (Nowell, 1960).
-assesses lymphocyte responsiveness to antigens or allogeneic cells.
Lymphokine assays
-various lymphokines are released from lymphocytes following stimulation by antigens, mitogens, surface immunoglobulins, and various membrane receptors.
Macrophage migration inhibitory factor
-production of macrophage migration inhibitory factor (MIF) is correlated with development of delayed hypersensitivity responses on skin testing.
Leukocyte migration inhibitory factor (LMIF)
-produced by either T or B lymphocytes.
Serum protein electrophoresis
-provides an overview of more than 100 serum proteins
-good screening test for the presence or absence of normal blood constituents.
-identification of abnormal spikes Þ gammopathies such as Waldenstrom's macroglobulinemia or myeloma.
Immunoelectrophoresis
-combines electrophoretic separation of serum proteins with immunodiffusion using monospecific antisera.
Erythrocyte sedimentation rate
-a simple means of serially monitoring patients with a diverse range of inflammatory disorders.
-major disadvantages are its nonspecificity and relative insensitivity.
-determined by the serum viscosity; \ substances such as fibrinogen, acute-phase reactants, macroglobulins,
which are often associated with chronic inflammatory states, have a significant effect on elevating the ESR.
Cryoglobulins
-systemic diseases associated with presence of serum immunoglobulins have the property of forming
precipitates in the cold.
-Autoimmune, neoplastic, and infectious diseases have cryoglobulins at some point in their clinical course.
eg: lupus nephritis, rheumatoid vasculitis, Sjögren's syndrome, and polyarteritis nodosa.
occult infections, (eg chronic hepatitis B or bacterial endocarditis, lymphoproliferative disorders)
Quantitative immunoglobulins
-Normally in adults the distribution is:
85% IgG, 10-15% IgA, 5-10% IgM.
Antinuclear antibody
-these have an overlap region in which normal patients and diseased patients both show positive responses. Here one must use additional clinical criteria to confirm the suspected diagnosis.
-patients in whom ANA is strikingly positive at high dilution, Þ is diagnostic of an autoimmune state.
-In general, ANA is positive in 50% of pts with scleroderma; 30% of pts with rh arthritis & 7% of normal pts.
Anti-DNA antibodies
-are measured in patients with collagen vascular diseases,
the specific ANA is classified as: -native double-stranded DNA (nDNA) or
-single-stranded DNA (ssDNA).
-anti-nDNA is highly associated with SLE, and its presence parallels the activity of the disease.
-anti-ssDNA is less specific, found in many types of collagen vascular disease.
C1Q-binding assay
-Ý C1Q binding provide Þ strong evidence for circulating immune complexes of the type that interact with the classic pathway of complement activation (IgG and IgM).
Raji cell assay
-detects soluble IC’s in serum & is based on binding of IC’s to Raji cells via complement receptors.
-unreliable in SLE and other diseases where antilymphocyte antibodies.
Summary
The following tests are most often helpful in screening for immune-mediated deafness:
1. ANA
2. Sedimentation rate
3. C1Q binding
4. Raji cell assay
5. Rheumatoid factor
6. Cryoglobulins
7. Urinalysis
8. FTA-ABS
B
ibliography:
Cummings, C. Otolaryngology. c
hapter 164Gates Current Therapeutics
Scott Brown, , Otolaryngology
Schucknect, Pathology of the Ear
| HOME |
Disclaimer
Please note: The above is intended as a general guideline only for Dr. Becvarovski’s patients.
This material should not be used for purposes of diagnosis or treatment without consulting a physician.
Each patient is an individual and should be treated accordingly.
Please contact our rooms if you are concerned or require any further information.
Dr Zoran Becvarovski MBBS, FRACS
Consulting Rooms Hospital Appointments
St George Private Medical Complex St George Public Hospital
Suite 7A, Level 5, St George Private Hospital
1 South Street Kogarah 2217 Hurstville Community Private Hospital
Telephone: 9553 0066
Fax: 9553 0444
![]()